Soundraw and Suno are two of the most popular AI music generators. But are they worth your time and investment?
Suno is infamous for using copyrighted music to train its AI models and is facing copyright infringement lawsuits. Soundraw is known for lacking originality in the music it creates, and creators often complain about getting copyright strikes.
Which one of these tools will be ideal for content creators? Or should you opt for an alternative to both?
Today, we put an end to the confusion: Soundraw vs. Suno. Let’s get started.
TL; DR
Overview of Suno and Soundraw AI Music Generators
Before we discuss the comparison between Suno and Soundraw in detail, here’s a quick background on both tools.
Soundraw
Soundraw allows users to generate royalty-free music. It offers tools to shorten intros, customize song structure, and rearrange choruses. Soundraw also allows the distribution and monetization of the generated music.
Find Soundraw alternatives here.
Suno
Suno is an AI song-generation tool that lets you create full lyrical songs using text prompts. It allows users to generate instrumentals, voices, and songs using input from different genres and styles. Suno also lets you upload tracks and generate similar tracks inspired by the uploaded piece.
Suno vs. Soundraw Comparison: The Ultimate Faceoff
We are centering our comparison on the four significant factors
Suno vs. Soundraw: Which is better at generating music?
While both tools have slightly distinct offerings, they often generate similar background music.
Suno generates lyrical songs, but it starts repeating sections of the song to create a full-length song. Users say iterating ideas into songs requires significant effort, trials, and errors, but you get the output.
Source
Soundraw generates 15 track options in one go, but they all sound similar. It also reduces the genre options when you choose moods, restricting your creativity and options.
Source
Winner: Suno
Suno vs. Soundraw: Which tool offers better customization?
Suno is a text-based AI music generator, meaning customization also happens through text prompts. In the Custom mode, you can write your lyrics, explain the style you need, and give the track your preferred title. This can feel restrictive if you are not well-versed with music terminologies.
Soundraw offers better customization options. You can control length, BPM, instruments, volume, tempo, key, genre, mood, and theme options. Using the mixer, you can change the intensity of each instrument to your liking.
Winner: Soundraw
Suno vs. Soundraw: Which tool is more affordable?
Here’s a quick comparison of the pricing:
Now, Suno offers a basic free plan with a limit of 10 songs and non-commercial terms. The plan is pretty straightforward and cheaper than Soundraw.
Soundraw’s pricing plan is very confusing. Its free plan is not mentioned on the pricing page and offers nothing besides allowing you to play around with the tool. The pricing starts at $16.99 for creators with unlimited downloads. However, the artist plan starts at $29.99 with a limit of just ten songs.
Does this mean the Creator’s plan compromises on quality?
Winner: Suno
Suno vs. Soundraw: Which tool is claim-free for copyright?
Soundraw and Suno both fall short of this particular feature.
While you may receive copyright claims on the AI-generated music tracks with Soundraw, Suno faces a significant copyright infringement case with the Recording Industry Association of America® (RIAA), which claims that Suno exploited copyright music to train its AI.
Users have received copyright claims even for using Soundraw samples in their content, which is the last thing a content creator wants to deal with. There’s a lot at stake if your content gets a copyright strike. You lose credibility, likes, views, and comments, and all your effort goes to waste.
Suno fails terribly at creating original music, which is now costing it $150,000 for each unauthorized use of copyrighted music.
So, does this tool should even be considered?
Source
Winner: None. Both Soundraw and Suno are not reliable when it comes to copyright claims.
Suno vs. Soundraw: Can you earn using these tools?
Soundraw allows you to monetize the music. You can use it commercially and distribute it on platforms like Spotify and Apple Music. You also get recording royalties for the music generated using Soundraw.
Suno offers ‘general commercial terms’ for the AI-generated music. Unfortunately, it doesn’t share any more information on the pricing page. You must dig into the Help section and find the information on licensing terms.
This creates a blind spot for busy content creators who must go on a treasure hunt to find the correct information. Soundraw is pretty transparent about this.
However, if we keep this aside, Suno does offer monetization on YouTube with Pro and Premier plans. Suno is talked about quite fondly for monetization.
Winner: Suno for monetization; Soundraw for clarity and transparency
Suno vs. Soundraw: What existing users are saying?
Let’s check what users are saying about these tools:
Suno
Trustpilot review: 2.8 (62 reviews)
If we leave copyright infringement aside, the quality of music generated by Suno has reduced exponentially. The repetitive music makes it almost impossible to use anything 99% of time, as per users.
Some Pros and Cons based on user reviews:
Pros
Cons
Saundraw
Trustpilot review: 3.1 (10 reviews)
While Soundraw has some good reviews from users who only need some music, here are there. However, users complain consistently about generating the same beats and music.
Some Pros and Cons based on user reviews:
Pros
Cons
Suno vs. Soundraw: Which AI Music Generator is Better for Content Creators?
We cannot sugarcoat this.
As per the lawsuits, Suno does not follow ethical AI practices, so we cannot recommend using it for music generation.
As for Soundraw, it comes with merits and demerits. While it uses proprietary algorithms and data sets created by its in-house music producers, it sometimes receives copyright claims. Some other notable issues with Soundraw are:
Since both tools have issues, what can a content creator use to generate music?
Beatoven.ai: A Great Alternative to Both Suno and Soundraw
Beatoven.ai is one of the best alternatives to ditching the issues of Suno and Soundraw. It offers royalty-free music, a perpetual license, and extensive customization options.
But what sets Beatoven.ai apart from other tools?
Beatoven.ai sets the bar high when generating ethical AI music. Certified by Fairly Trained, it collaborates with artists, fairly compensates them for their contribution, and generates 100% unique ethical music.
To improve music production and ensure the ethical use of AI, it has recently partnered with AIforMusic, an initiative by Roland Corporation and Universal Music Group.
What do you get with Beatoven.ai besides ethical music?
Beatoven.ai’s ethical practices for using AI to generate music were also recognized at the esteemed Nasscom Awards. In the Telecom, Media, and Entertainment category, it was recognized as a ‘Game-changing AI Brand’.
Trusted by brands like Google for their music needs, Beatoven.ai is the perfect choice for worry-free and royalty-free music.
So, what are you waiting for?
Sreyashi Chatterjee is a SaaS content marketing consultant. When she is not writing or thinking about writing, she is watching Netflix or reading a thriller novel while sipping coffee.